It is
also important to think of genes as existing in populations. How good an
allele is depends very much on the other genes present. There is a very
interesting instance of moths not behaving as expected when moved from one
gene pool to another.
The Lesser Yellow Underwing moth
is normally yellowish brown but there is a variant, which is blackish (curtisii).
The variant is not found in England but co exists in Scotland and the Isles
with the normal variant (comes). The curtisii dark colour pattern is nearly
completely dominant to the normal comes pattern.
The hybrids between the two look like the curtisii even though they bear the
genes of both. Ford (Oxford) caught specimens of the moths from various
islands and the Scottish mainland. Evidence showed that the curtisii gene
was dominant on the island and mainland. Based on this it was expected that
when the moths from different islands were mated that the normal dominance
pattern would hold. But it never and the curtisii dominance completely
disappeared and a complete range of intermediaries turned up in the hybrids,
as if there was no dominance. The conclusion was that the curtisii gene
should only be thought of as having its effects in the presence in a context
of a suite of other genes. Some of which it switches on. The above is
mentioned by Richard Dawkins in his book
Unweaving The Rainbow, which is some
good recommended reading.
This
idea will be important when looking at various bloodlines found in
predominately different areas of the globe. Just how good the genes perform
when transported from one region to another may well be dependent on local
racing conditions and the bloodlines found in that region.
By way
of illustration, a line that may be successful in North America on dirt
tracks may have difficulty in performing at the same level in Australasia
where the broodmare population is best at producing turf horses. The
characteristics for success on dirt may vary from what is required to
perform on turf surfaces and vice versa. How genes are expressed, being
dependent on the genes present in the local population.
Mr
Prospector and Sir Ivor might well fall into this category. Mr Prospector
has disappointed to date, as a sire prospect in Australasia and it might be
that his gene pool is not that well suited to the Australasian broodmare.
On the other hand in NZ we have done reasonably well with some bloodlines
that have disappointed elsewhere. Sir Ivor, comes to mind. That is, to get
the best out of a set of genes they need to be in the right gene population
and environment.
Some
horses seem best suited to bloodlines found in different regions.
Like everything to do with breeding there will be some notable
exceptions. It is essential that you treat your breeding stock as unique
individuals.